Search

Error report

processed

Tragedy (Bastien)

Submitted by

jojo

On December 15, 2004

Performance

Error description

Tragedy


I also found some more info on the song "Tragedy" by Gerald Nelson and Fred Burch.

The next info is from the inlay of the CD: "Fernwood Rock 'n' Roll": Thomas Wayne came to Fernwood in 1958 and made a scorching debut with "You're the one that done it / This time", which even achieved a license deal with Mercury, but did not chart.

From Paducah, Kentucky came Gerald Nelson, who had already recorded "Tragedy" with his band the Escorts in 1958.

Co-written with advertising man Fred Burch, the song was offered to Scotty Moore, who recorded it with Thomas and provided the eerie guitarfigures along with the almost inaudible bass of Bill Mack and the female chanting of the De-Lons. This angst ridden, haunting teen ballad finally peaked at no. 5 on the Billboard charts, but sadly, although creeping onto the bottom rungs of various charts with "Follow-up" 45's, Thomas never again came close to a hit record and eventually became a studio engineer. There was at least one consolation for Thomas in that Elvis Presley recorded his song "The Girl next door (went a walkin')", the original of which is included here. Chip Moman's song "This time" originally by Thomas and also on this CD would later become a huge hit for Troy Shondell, while Thomas would end his days on August 17th, 1971 in a car accident.

History

Comment by Bastien
2004-12-29 10:01:01 UTC

You also posted this in another thread, but I'm still looking for the correct anme of Gerard Nelson's band, and maybe release information.

 
Comment by Bastien
2005-01-23 17:03:59 UTC

The following link seems to indicate the band name was "The Escorts":

http://www.singtoread.com/About_Music_Producer.html

 
Comment by jojo
submitter
2005-01-23 17:36:57 UTC

Goods search Bastien.

 
Comment by Bastien
2005-04-10 11:56:34 UTC

There was at least one consolation for Thomas in that Elvis Presley recorded his song "The Girl next door (went a walkin')", the original of which is included here.


Another tough one, trying to find out which was the first version.


Thomas Wayne:

1960-05

http://koti.mbnet.fi/wdd/fernwood.htm

http://rcs.law.emory.edu/rcs/artists/w/wayn7600.htm


Elvis Presley:

1960-05

The Great Rock Discography

1960-04

http://home.wanadoo.nl/robs.epsite/albums/alb011.htm

 
Comment by jojo
submitter
2005-04-10 16:39:37 UTC

Elvis recorded this song on 4 april 1960.

Apparentley the composer recorded it in 1959.

This is also mentioned in the book: 'Elvis his life from Ato Z'


http://users.pandora.be/davidneale/elvis/originals/list3.html#23458


Therefore I go for the composer of this song as the original version.


JoJo greets

 
Comment by Bastien
2005-06-21 18:46:56 UTC

Contacted the webmaster of http://users.pandora.be/davidneale/elvis/originals/index.html to ask what his source is.

 
Comment by Bastien
2005-08-09 18:57:56 UTC

There was at least one consolation for Thomas in that Elvis Presley recorded his song "The Girl next door (went a walkin')", the original of which is included here.


Added

 
Comment by Bastien
2005-08-09 19:07:27 UTC

Chip Moman's song "This time" originally by Thomas and also on this CD would later become a huge hit for Troy Shondell


Added

 
Change by shs
2016-03-09 00:00:00 UTC
Conversion from forum topic to error report