Search

Error report

rejected

Iko Iko by Charmaine Neville

Submitted by

Tunesmith

On January 1, 2023

Performance

Error description

Why are this cover and those by Dora the Explorer and Six String Yada included here in a separate section, where the writers are the three members of The Dixie Cups together with Sugar Boy and not here

Jock-A-Mo

where all the similar versions are.

Attachments

History

Comment by sebcat
2023-01-01 12:04:39 UTC

Tunesmith from what I can see Bastien set up the adaptation separately and then Oliver One Rodders200 Ginger and camembert electrique added versions to this adaptation, as did you initially - Submission #179202.

I have a question though about whether this should really be set up as a separate adaptation if there is nothing musically or lyrically different. It feels more like an “unjustified adaptation” which we have a tag for in the database - Guideline: Unjustified adaptations.

Last updated by sebcat on 2023-01-01 12:15:37 UTC - Show original message

 
Change by Oliver One
2023-02-12 11:05:23 UTC
Status: open need info
 
Change by Tunesmith
submitter
2023-02-12 22:28:32 UTC
Status: need info open
 
Comment by Tunesmith
submitter
2023-02-12 22:28:32 UTC

I have nothing more to add to my error report.

 
Comment by Oliver One
2023-02-13 07:00:35 UTC

I simply followed the credits on back cover

attachment

 
Change by Oliver One
2023-02-13 07:00:35 UTC
Attachment: image.png
 
Change by Oliver One
2023-02-13 07:20:32 UTC
Status: open rejected