Cover submission

processed

Love Hurts by The Fevers [BR]

Submitted by

VirileVagabond

On August 21, 2018

Performance

performance

Love Hurts

By The Fevers [BR]

Cover of

Processed by

sebcat

On January 3, 2019

Created performance

Language
English
Release
The Fevers Volume 8
Release date
2000
Format
Album CD

Additional comments and sources

History

Comment by sebcat
2018-09-01 12:27:24 UTC
 

Were these two tracks, Love Hurts and Love Will Keep Us Together, previously unreleased?

 
Comment by VirileVagabond
submitter
2018-09-01 14:19:34 UTC
 

I couldn't find any earlier release when originally researched....

 
Change by sebcat
2018-12-24 20:46:19 UTC
 
Assignee: sebcat
 
Comment by sebcat
2018-12-24 20:47:11 UTC
 

We can't add this one without more evidence about when it was first released, unfort.

 
Change by sebcat
2018-12-24 20:47:18 UTC
 
Status: open incomplete
 
Comment by VirileVagabond
submitter
2018-12-25 03:08:36 UTC
 

Seb… With all due respect, you're getting a bit silly with stuff like this. While there could have been some yet unfound English singles from back in the day, the most likely situation (based on what we do know) is that these were either unreleased recordings from those sessions or new recordings created for the reissue. One might as well delete the entire site based on the possibility of every entry being recorded or released earlier....


Hell, pretty much all of those bossa nova covers could have been released earlier on some yet to be discovered tribute, etc.


As always, my standard statement that your decision here will likely only result in a later resubmission and duplicate editor efforts.

 
Change by sebcat
2019-01-03 20:20:31 UTC
 
Status: incomplete open
 
Change by sebcat
2019-01-03 20:23:59 UTC
 
Status: open processed
 
Comment by sebcat
2019-01-03 20:23:59 UTC
 

Actually this is the way that the work-flow on the site is supposed to work. If the submitter has not provided all required information to process the case, then the editor should mark the case as "need info" and then "incomplete", pending further review. But I did quite a bit of research this afternoon on this one to get it on the site.

 
Comment by VirileVagabond
submitter
2019-01-04 00:29:29 UTC
 

Seems like I found this on AMG when I originally researched but couldn't when I submitted. That would explain the our differing release dates. I don't trust that Jan 1, 2003 iTunes release date and am surprised that you did (unless you found 2003 elsewhere?)….


I also recall finding autogens when originally researched that were not found when submitted....


Finally, I believe that "incomplete" is treated as a rejection, removing the submission from the list of covers under the applicable work. That removal is my concern and objection. I also believe that you have agreed with me that how things should work is that (absent enough to process) the first step is a targeted "need info" to the submitter, the second step is a general "need info"/"incomplete" that leaves the matter open for anyone to continue research but leaves the matter listed under the work.


The only time I could justify an effective rejection is when there is uncertainty that A artist even covered B song and there is little or no support. When we know that A artist covered B song which was released on C compilation, leaving the matter open until the original release details are determined with reasonable certainty seems the only proper treatment.

Last updated by VirileVagabond on 2019-01-04 00:37:25 UTC - Show original message

 
Comment by sebcat
2019-01-04 00:37:26 UTC
 

Yes I don’t trust iTunes either - so got the release date from CD back cover. Hurrah Smile