Search

Error report

processed

Don't Cry for Me Argentina written by Tim Rice

Submitted by

andyk

On June 6, 2018

Error description

This song is not an adaptation of "Oh What a Circus". It, like that song, was written for the musical Evita - that is the only connection between the two. It was written by Andrew Lloyd Webber (music) and Tim Rice (lyrics).

History

Comment by Bastien
2018-06-07 07:52:14 UTC

But it's the same melody, isn't it?

 
Change by Bastien
2018-06-07 07:52:17 UTC
Status: open need info
 
Change by andyk
submitter
2018-06-07 14:53:26 UTC
Status: need info open
 
Comment by andyk
submitter
2018-06-07 14:53:26 UTC

Umm, sure, but I don't think it useful or illuminating to recognise that by the term 'adaptation. In fact quite a lot of the tune is distinct, and of course the rhythm and flavour are very different. Rice wrote two sets of words to the Webber tune - I don't think calling the second set an adaptation or even a derivative helps at all. To put it on the same level as the Swedish translation of the song(s) is wrong, or at best misleading. However, if that's the best of way of expressing the link within the Secondhand Songs site, so be it I guess. Unhappy

 
Comment by Bastien
2019-02-12 11:13:58 UTC

I see your point. Reshuffled it a little, let me know what you think.

 
Change by Bastien
2019-11-08 16:55:22 UTC
Status: open need info
 
Comment by andyk2
2019-11-09 16:20:19 UTC

Sorry for the delay (There seems to be a problem with the site - I've had to create a new account to reply) I think your shuffle has helped a little. Thanks for taking the time to do it.

 
Comment by Tar Heel
2019-11-09 16:30:25 UTC

Not sure why I decided to check this thread, but interesting. I'm not familiar with all of the related works for Evita, but the exchange above suggests that the different songs share some common musical elements, a feature not that uncommon for a musical or a film.


Seems some guideline may be advisable to handle this type of situation to distinguish from an adaption.....

 
Change by Bastien
2019-11-14 17:52:51 UTC
Status: need info processed