When I Grow Too Old to Dream / Remember by Mandy Patinkin

First recording by Paul Whiteman and His Orchestra - Vocal Refrain by The King's Men (December 17, 1934)

First theatrical release by Ramon Novarro & Evelyn Laye (January 11, 1935)

First recording and first broadcast by Charmian Carr (1966 / November 16, 1966)

First release by Victoria Mallory (May 1973)