Search

Search message

Showing 1-20 out of 1239.

Board Subject Content User Date
1 Feedback Performing Artist Credits: Soundtrack Composers Another situation where we appear to have inconsistent treatments and an applicable editor failing to reconcile or otherwise provide requested guidance. In short, should and when does an overall soundtrack composer get a performing artist credit? The matter that triggered this post: https://secondh VirileVagabond 2021-03-01
2 Feedback Re: 2 Recordings, 2 Aliases, 1 Work Another? [[artist|146677|Kenton Files]] [[performance|819798|The Rain Must Fall]] [[performance|819801|The Rain Must Fall]] VirileVagabond 2021-02-21
3 Discussion Re: What Is SHS: A Researched Source or Compiler? {@ {@@[[message|206656|Quote from walt]]@@} The remainder showing proper credits on credible releases also qualify IMO. @} Curious, what's a "credible release"? How does one know the credits are proper without audio confirmation? Performances can be titled in one language but sung in another VirileVagabond 2021-02-17
4 Feedback Re: 2 Recordings, 2 Aliases, 1 Work Now (maybe) three recordings, 2 Aliases. 1 Work: https://secondhandsongs.com/error-report/43231 VirileVagabond 2021-02-17
5 Discussion Re: What Is SHS: A Researched Source or Compiler? {@ {@@[[message|206642|Quote from baggish]]@@} Song-writing credits must be copied (and they must be copied from a fixed set of sources) and there is no need to research them properly. @} Decided to expand a bit on this.... Given my level of SHS activity, including error reports, I still rarely VirileVagabond 2021-02-15
6 Discussion Re: What Is SHS: A Researched Source or Compiler? Wow... First, thanks Bag for the response. I really didn't expect any. Second, I can appreciate the "legal" vs. "actual" songwriters differences of opinion, but I consider that a different question. We have to default to one or the other, and the "legal" is rarely in dispute at any given point in VirileVagabond 2021-02-15
7 Discussion Had To Share! It will be a long time before I see something like this again on my screen! :) OWN COVER SUBMISSIONS '''11111''' VirileVagabond 2021-02-11
8 Feedback 2 Recordings, 2 Aliases, 1 Work Looks silly and duplicates to me: [[artist|133267|George Sarah]] [[performance|721712|On the Run]] [[performance|721708|On the Run]] VirileVagabond 2021-02-11
9 Requests Zoe Tyler [[artist|46257|Zoë Tyler]] Struggled with how to notice the editors on this matter; ended up here. First, found the release below, which may be different recordings than those already on site, may be the same released earlier, or the same released later. I can't find a release date either way: VirileVagabond 2021-02-10
10 Discussion What Is SHS: A Researched Source or Compiler? A recent exchange got me thinking, is SHS an independently researched source for the works, performances, etc. on site or is SHS simply a site that compiles and archives the data found on other sources and sites? Other than offering a "one stop shop" for cover songs documented on various other si VirileVagabond 2021-02-09
11 Feedback Re: Tags: a cappella release (Release), A cappella (Performance) {@ {@@[[message|206463|Quote from Bastien]]@@} I don't appreciate the tone of your last post VV. It feels ad hominem and passive aggressive, to say the least. @} As does a, in reality non-responsive, simple "not the case." I ten to react in kind. I could expand far more, but have elected to l VirileVagabond 2021-02-08
12 Feedback Re: Tags: a cappella release (Release), A cappella (Performance) {@ {@@[[message|206437|Quote from sebcat]]@@} {@ {@@[[message|206436|Quote from VirileVagabond]]@@}Frankly, it appears to me (and I can safely say to others) that these tags were added because you wanted them, notwithstanding what consistency problems they may create. @} Not the [[topic|73983|case VirileVagabond 2021-02-07
13 Feedback Re: Tags: a cappella release (Release), A cappella (Performance) {@ {@@[[message|206428|Quote from sebcat]]@@} Yes. A cappella refers to vocal performances without any accompanying instruments. It can be performed in any musical genre. @} Not really. or at least not really common enough to justify a tag. [[performance|241122|Black Water]] breaks into an a cap VirileVagabond 2021-02-07
14 Feedback Re: Tags: a cappella release (Release), A cappella (Performance) {@ {@@[[message|206421|Quote from Bastien]]@@} {@ {@@[[message|206362|Quote from VirileVagabond]]@@}why does this genre get a tag while others do not? @} Is it indeed a genre? Debatable. You can have an capella rendition in very different genres of music. @} First, thanks for the timely respon VirileVagabond 2021-02-07
15 News Re: Submit Joint Performers via the Submission These are all likely the same errors as reported below: https://secondhandsongs.com/topic/76503 ..., though the trigger may "move around". VirileVagabond 2021-02-07
16 Discussion Re: Scarborough Fair (Trad) vs Scarborough Fair / Canticle (Simon & Garfunkel) {@ {@@[[message|206368|Quote from jojo]]@@} This will work, but I would add this: 4. Guitar arrangement was copied from [[artist|13244|Martin Carthy]]'s [[performance|22329|Scarborough Fair]] @} I can see a comment re: an arrangement on a performance, but not a work. VirileVagabond 2021-02-06
17 News Re: Submit Joint Performers via the Submission With more experience, some observations: a) I still maintain the "+ Artist" should be changed to something more intuitive; b) The first Common name field should not auto-fill from the Performer field. For instance "VV, DB & Seb Trio" auto-appears, forcing one to edit that field every time. On VirileVagabond 2021-02-06
18 Feedback Tags: a cappella release (Release), A cappella (Performance) Examples: [[release|220744|Taking the Fall]] [[performance|752139|Brick]] If anything, a cappella is a genre. I again ask why does this genre get a tag while others do not? Since I (and I believe others) have asked before without a response or explanation: [[user|51650|sebcat]] Tagged as likel VirileVagabond 2021-02-06
19 Discussion Re: Scarborough Fair (Trad) vs Scarborough Fair / Canticle (Simon & Garfunkel) {@ {@@[[message|206348|Quote from sebcat]]@@} 2. Clear up the wrongly assigned instrumentals pointed out by [[user|261|jojo]] . 3. For vocal versions, use the lyrics to determine whether to assign to [[work|22328|Scarborough Fair]] or [[work|14508|Scarborough Fair / Canticle]]. 4. For instrumenta VirileVagabond 2021-02-06
20 Discussion Paradize by Bengt Hennings [[artist|147335|Bengt Hennings]] [[artist|216|Mark Knopfler]] After a quick sample, I don't recognize this recording supposedly written by Knopfler. Maybe someone has an interest: https://www.discogs.com/Bengt-Hennings-95-Vi-G%C3%A5r-En-Liten-Stund-H%C3%A4r-P%C3%A5-Jorden/release/9945132 Pro VirileVagabond 2021-02-05