Search

Cover submission

processed

Die Antwort weiss ganz allein der Wind by Peter, Paul & Mary

Submitted by

besf

On November 9, 2021

Performance

performance

Die Antwort weiss ganz allein der Wind

By Peter, Paul & Mary

Completeness

93%

Processed by

camembert electrique

On December 10, 2022

Language
German
Release
Die Antwort Weiß Ganz Allein Der Wind

Die Antwort Weiß Ganz Allein Der Wind

Label
Electrola
Catalog number
E 22 612
Format
Single 7"

Additional comments and sources

Sources used:


Other links to allow for verification:

History

Change by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 20:28:34 UTC
Assignee: camembert electrique
 
Comment by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 20:50:44 UTC

Thanks for this submission. Obviously, the recording artist isn't Peter, Paul and Mary, but Marlene Dietrich, whose recording was already in the database, which is why I couldn't add the track. The same goes for the B-side, "Paff".

All I could do was therefore to add the single and attribute the already listed tracks to it, too. Unfortunately, all above said includes having to reject the submission.

Last updated by camembert electrique on 2022-12-10 20:52:08 UTC - Show original message

 
Change by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 20:52:42 UTC
Status: open duplicate
 
Comment by besf
submitter
2022-12-10 21:24:44 UTC

I don't understand it.

There are two different recordings:

Marlene Dietrich:

and Peter, P & M: (higher tone and 3 different voices singing) The latest documented by the release: https://www.discogs.com/release/1560085-Peter-Paul-And-Mary-Die-Antwort-Wei%C3%9…

So what is not clear to me or to you?

 
Comment by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 22:03:24 UTC

The link https://www.discogs.com/release/17521774-Marlene-Dietrich-Die-Antwort-Wei%C3%9F-… goes for Marlene Dietrich's single, as does all the external data shown. The only thing that doesn't is the clip. So, what would you say am I supposed to do?

Following up some Marlene Dietrich stuff, I in the meantime and accidentally stumbled over another and by catalogue number earlier release of PPM's German version. I will add the release you now refer to, too, and attribute the track to you.

PS: In the middle of the upper row of covers shown on thre front sleeve of the compilation the video was taken from, you'll find the one of the earlier release I added.

Last updated by camembert electrique on 2022-12-10 22:12:56 UTC - Show original message

 
Change by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 22:09:06 UTC
Status: duplicate open
 
Comment by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 22:09:14 UTC
 
Change by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 22:09:18 UTC
Status: open processed
 
Comment by camembert electrique
2022-12-10 23:51:49 UTC

According to 45cat, the Die Antwort weiß ganz allein der Wind single was released in 1964, which appears much more likely than 1968...

Last updated by camembert electrique on 2022-12-10 23:51:58 UTC - Show original message