Search

Error report

rejected

Make You Feel My Love

Submitted by

maryhelen

On January 25, 2017

Error description

In the columns, instead of this:

Versions


Make You Feel My Love written by Bob Dylan English

Title Performer Release date Info

Make You Feel My Love Bob Dylan September 30, 1997 First recording


I think this is meant to read that BD release date is September 30, 1997, but he recorded it in January 1997 to match the info at the tp (by his pic) which reads:


First recording January 1997

Make You Feel My Love Bob Dylan

If not can you please clear up the mismatch?

History

Comment by Bastien
2017-01-25 06:21:03 UTC

No, it's meant the way it is. What you're looking for is probably Make You Feel My Love

 
Change by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 06:21:09 UTC

Description: Show

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 06:23:26 UTC

M lookiing at "

Make You Feel My Love the titles look alike to me

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 06:26:21 UTC

It si the same song-- eiher way, the information of first recording does not match. At the top by the pic it has January 1997, then at the column, it has first recordiing September 1997 and Billy Joesl as first release in Aug 1997. ???

 
Comment by Bastien
2017-01-25 06:27:36 UTC

Your link is the work, the composition by Bob Dylan

My link is the performance, the singing and playing, by Bob Dylan

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 06:28:56 UTC

Look at it: there are 2 different dated for BD first recording January 1997 at the top, then by the columns first recording Sept 1997-- which is it?

Then when is BD release date, that makes Billy Joel's release date of Aug 1997 the first release date???

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 06:34:05 UTC

Ok i found it on wikipedia. This is how is should read on SHS:


from the album Time Out of Mind

Released September 30, 1997

Recorded January 1997

 
Comment by Bastien
2017-01-25 06:34:17 UTC

then by the columns first recording Sept 1997-- which is it?


Released in Sept 1997, not recorded.

 
Comment by Bastien
2017-01-25 06:37:58 UTC

Ok i found it on wikipedia. This is how is should read on SHS:


from the album Time Out of Mind

Released September 30, 1997

Recorded January 1997


Yes, that's exactly how we have it listed: Make You Feel My Love

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 14:46:04 UTC

No it is NOT how you have it--right next to the "recording date" , September 1997, Under Info. it reads "First Recording." One has to look back up to see that the first recording date is January 1997.


It's too bad you can't see how this set is confuing, especially to a non-regular user of SHS.

 
Comment by maryhelen
submitter
2017-01-25 14:47:06 UTC

Your link is the work, the composition by Bob Dylan

My link is the performance, the singing and playing, by Bob Dylan


What???